So, I decided to look further into his work and see if I still feel the same. My goal here is for this not to come across as the usual nerd rage. Trust me when I say, my intention is not to go on a bashing rant. With all that being said, I selected what I felt was a good sampling of his work. The following are the books I read:.
Pretty much standard storytelling. Morrison seems to start a story, goes off and tells another story, then comes back to the first part of the story to finish it. WE3 is an amazing story. Personally, I think would work pretty well. It was a little surreal but, still an enjoyable read. As was the Invisibles. The same goes for Steed And Mrs. New X-Men, for example. The characters acted out of character, like the way they all just accepted Xorn who was Magneto in disguise into their inner circle.
The doors were opened and the enrollment went up to where most private school levels are…to around students. That made sense. All-Star Superman won an Eisner Award but personally?
I read it multiple times at this point and I still remain unimpressed. A lot of people say this is the quintessential Superman.
I completely disagree. It truly seems all over the place. When the project was first announced, the storyline was supposed to be about the 12 labors of Superman that would span over 12 issues. Last Jump to page: Results 1 to 15 of This was the first run from start to finish I ever read and honestly almost immediately I utterly despised it. There were ideas in it I liked ruby quartz contact lenses, why had no one done that before? But so often I've seen reviews online or heard on podcasts Jay and Miles I'm not even asking WHY people liked it, just if anyone else felt as I did about it and if so what turned you off about it?
I hated it. Everything could have been done in a better way. I didn't like that he killed jean and marvel followed that for more than a decade. Last edited by phoenixzero23; at PM. Another of his strenght is being unexpected and dramatic, something that probably come from his love for the Silver Age, but charactherization often suffers for it and i'm not even getting in how weird his dialogue can be "Oh god, not the Search of Cyclops again" da fuck Charles?
But to answer your question, as part of the main continuity, no, i don't like it, he went too far in many aspects and got most of the characthers personalities wrong. As a weird AU deconstruction from the early s, is kind of fun and have his place, i just really wish that it wasn't in the continuity. You made Spider-Man sad, congratulations. To me, Morrison's run is that horrible class you decided to take in college because of credits.
I love it the way other people love Watchmen. Last edited by CRaymond; at PM. The cowardice of killing off a popular female character because they wanted the pet character to have a new girlfriend without the continued existence of the old one is the height of neckbeardism. Still, I find the run to be a net positive overall, considering concepts and characters that were established and characterizations that were played so well that they caught on and made waves that are still rolling to this day.
Its horrible, he hates the franchise and tried his darndest to ruin it, the only people are are really into his run are Morrisonfans who hate everything that he hasn't written, it's like a cult. Cat Beast is the worst Ew, that Magneto Otherwise, no weaknesses. It was not bad, but it was not the modern classic the Morrison fanboys like to think it is. It was basically a greatest hits of X-Men troupes with Morrison touch.
Evil Magneto? The ending was bad and an actual editor would have told Morrison from the start "no your not having Magneto go full nazi and your not killing him off", but then again it is marvel and editors do basically nothing. Originally Posted by Zero Hunter. Originally Posted by phoenixzero The fact that none of the characters were allowed to be smarter than the author, that really drove me nuts.
He makes a plan all his life that is undone by the end of the book in an instant. The psychiatrist sits with Rorschach for five minutes and Rorschach tells a super banal story of how he became a vigilante and the psychiatrist cracks. I took potshots at him in the media.
And that made him angry so then I would get worse.
0コメント